School Board Gets Input on Capital Projects At Meeting
Residents and students came out in force to comment on renovations to the athletic fields, the Frost Auditorium and the use of solar power.
In a lively meeting Tuesday night, the Culver City Unified School District Board of Education heard an update on capital projects in the works, while trying to reassure the members of the public attending that none of the projects are being withdrawn from consideration.
The board also recognized the district's 15 new teachers and approved a Memo of Understanding that will enable the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health continue to provide mental health services for special education students in the district.
But with a crowd of parents, students and residents filling the Culver City Council chamber to overflowing, the main point of interest was the update on four capital improvement projects currently wending their way through the various processes needed to get construction underway.
The projects include extensive improvements to the athletic fields at Culver City High School, installing elevators in Culver City Middle School and in the high school, improvements to the high school's Robert Frost Auditorium, and the installation of solar panels on the rooves of the high school, middle school and Farragut Elementary School.
"It worries me greatly that this has become an 'us versus them,'" said Board Vice President Karlo Silbiger, adding that no one on the board wants to drop any of the four projects.
The problem, however, is that without various different grants, rebates and other money from the state, the combined cost of the project will be approximately $4 million more than the $12 million the district has in the various building funds that can only be used for building improvements and cannot be used for teacher salaries.
"It's just a matter of divvying up the money," Silbiger said.
All of the projects are in the earliest stages of the approval/construction process. An architect has been engaged for the sports complex and a Request For Proposal has gone out, seeking potential contractors for the solar panel project, which received four responses, only one of which was in full compliance with the what the RFP requested.
More than 16 people chose to speak on the various projects during the comment session after the presentation by Ali Delawalla, assistant superintendent of business services for the district.
Community members spoke in favor of all four projects, but voiced numerous concerns about the lack of detailed data or specific parts of each project and the lack of cost/benefit analyses in the plans outlined by Delawalla.
"What's missing are the specifics," resident Howard Mencken told the board. "What's the process for coming to completion?"
"I'd like to propose to slow down," said Jane Steinberg, requesting that the board offer up a full cost/benefit analysis for the projects and that they "seek the input of the parents."
On the other hand, Jerry Chabola, head of athletics at the high school pointed out that new turf on the fields is critically necessary, as students are getting injured from the uneven field.
"Education is the primary purpose of the field," Chabola said. "It's now time to step up and spend the money. Our facilities are not in good shape."
Chabola's remarks received a standing ovation from the many student athletes filling the chamber.
Many of the speakers expressed concerns about the delays in the project to install solar panels on school rooftops, including one unnamed man who expressed fear that the solar project would get lost among the other three projects.
The board, in turn, asked Delawalla to provide more specific breakdowns on project costs. Board member Katherine Paspalis also expressed concern that a potentially non-refundable deposit for a rebate from the California Solar Initiative had not been sent in, despite board requests to do so.
"I'm not thrilled about the $20,000 not being put in for the CSI," she said.
Delawalla had earlier said, answering Silbiger's question about it, that the deposit, or reservation fee, had not been sent in because the fee is only refundable if the project moves forward. Given that the project is not officially approved, the districts risks losing the $20,000.
The board's main concern, however, was to reassure the public that no one project was being favored over another.
"We're here for all the students," said Board member Professor Patricia Siever.
"Every single one of these projects is doable even with the money we have," Paspalis said, adding that the board might have to find extra grants to fund them, but that there were grants and other funds available. "We just have to be creative about it."
Board member Steven Gourley also epressed concern repeatedly that the board's Sustainability Committee appeared to have been left out of a key part of the Request For Proposal process on the solar panel project and insisted repeatedly that the committe be included at all phases of all of the projects.
"Are we using the Sustainability Committee as much as we could?" Gourley asked early in the meeting, insisting that the committee be involved not just on the solar panel project, but on all of the capital projects being considered and worked on, a request that was echoed by the other board members, as well.
Janet Chabola
11:15 am on Thursday, September 29, 2011
The renovations to Robert Frost and to the Athletic Complex have been discussed at length since 2004, with proposals to the school boards. The now defunct Community Budget Advisory Committee had urged the boards to use the Capital Improvement funds. Nothing had been done until Scott Zeidman encouraged the current board to get moving on Capital projects that should have been taken care of during the Measure T improvements, or shortly thereafter.
In 2005 all of the school sites were asked to submit their "wish list" of items to be repaired, replaced, or improved. Nearly 300 items were on the original list. After clearing items that were maintainence related, the District began working on the remaining requests. The list was eventually pared down to 22 projects. The only 4 items (7 of the 22 items comprised the Athletic Complex) that have never been taken care of are Robert Frost, Athletic Complex, Elevators and the Natatorium. The Board consisting of Russell, Wolkowitz, Bubar, Davis and Jessica Beagles-Roos supported all projects, but would only consider the Athletic Complex as 1 project since there was so much to be done.
The Solar proposal is the most recent project to be considered. The Budget Advisory Committee did discuss the merits of using Solar, but the cost/benefit of it couldn't be reconciled with the expense.
All of these projects are important. The issue is not which of them, but WHEN!
Amanda Copeland
5:20 pm on Thursday, September 29, 2011
Amanda Copeland will be there until the school board is either cleared of vicious litigators, or the board stops stonewalling on their misconduct with millions in litigation spent against our own special ed kids. If 116 emails or whatever Paspalus claims, aren't enough to convince them to stop litigating - then there will more emails. I copy the board on every litigation email exchanged with their million dollar lawfirm- that should give an idea of how badly my child is harassed by CCUSD litigation. I got some lovely support from the community after Tuesday night. Please don't let your fear of Scott Zeidman stop you from speaking out against this misconduct. Contact me amandafcopeland@gmail.com for help and to vote Zeidman out.
Amanda Copeland
5:23 pm on Thursday, September 29, 2011
By the way little has been said about the fantastic energy of all the students in the auditorium Tuesday night. What a wonderful treat it was to be among them and feel that enthusiasm!
Ken Browning
10:10 pm on Thursday, September 29, 2011
Well put Janet, the time is ripe. Even still, there IS time for due diligence when we can compare "apples to apples". When each project has balance sheets, projections, and timelines. No question, the value of each project has been proven countless times over. Correcting deficiencies, accident prevention and community pride come up again and again with all 4 projects. While the payback on the solar is not an IF but also a WHEN, and that money not flowing to the utility WILL be available for uses where other funds may not. This is how it has been explained time and again. Plus with solar, the conservation practices that were discussed early on in the meeting will be backed up by abundant, reliable, good old southern California sunshine. Future graduates will know that every time they flip a switch, they ARE part of the future and not the past.
Amanda Copeland
6:37 am on Saturday, October 1, 2011
Hey "Dennis" how many kids do you have in CCUSD?
Amanda Copeland
2:31 pm on Saturday, October 1, 2011
It's just odd because no one can seem to figure out who you are "Dennis" that's all. Your insults, your kids alleged insults and Zeidman's insults will not dissuade me in any way from bringing the facts out until they are asdressed- about the egregious malicious discriminatory waste of millions by the school board litgating against our special ed kids. Your blind refusal to acknowledge the state proof of 72 cases in the last 5 years at a cost of more than 1.5 million to our students makes you look, smell, and taste like Scott Zeidman. I will not give up this cause for my child or the other dozens of kids in
this district being buried and harassed by this litigation. If you don't like it you can think about attending another show on Tuesday nights, because I won't quit til it ends.
Amanda Copeland
2:36 pm on Saturday, October 1, 2011
I do invite the public to attend the upcoming trial of the case against my child filed by CCUSD- already at the cost of more than 50,000 to the district, for her allegedly not being assesssed. I'd like the public to see the proof of
at least 10 hours of assessments and observations of the child having already been completed by CCUSD and to
listen to the tape recording of their supervisor saying all the assessments have been completed. Please contact me for trial details if you'd like to
come observe amandafcopeland@gmail.com